Shadyside

Availability Calendar 2024: TBD


Shadyside is a quaint, two-story cottage originally constructed in 1894 and updated several times over the last few years. Recent improvements include a brand new kitchen, new flooring, and new appliances. The cottage has 3 bedrooms – one on the first floor and two upstairs – one full bathroom with shower (first floor), one half bath with toilet and laundry (first floor), and a half bath with toilet on the second floor. The cottage also has a living room, dining area, and enclosed porch on the first floor. The cottage has window A/C units in the upstairs bedrooms and a free-standing floor A/C unit on the first floor. Appliances include a stacked washer and dryer, dishwasher, refrigerator, oven, and microwave. The cottage also has an outdoor deck area on the east side with a gas grill.

  • Rental Fee: $1,300/week
  • Cleaning Fee: $150
    • Cleaning Professional: Jan Jensen
  • Sleeps: 6
  • 2 parking spots 50 feet from cottage
  • No pets allowed
  • No smoking allowed
  • Not wheelchair accessible

Contact: Missy McCain

Mt. Carmel

Availability Calendar 2024: June 1-7 and September


Charming and spacious blend of 1918 combined with new lower level expansion and kitchen upgrade in 1990. Handicap access ramp and generous deck were added in 2018. Adorable cottage large enough for all your family and friends. 

  • Rental Fee: $2,250/week
  • Cleaning Fee: Leave the cottage as clean as you find it
    • Cleaning Professional: Jan Jensen, 231-690-4800
  • Sleeps: 18
  • 2 parking spots in parking lot, one cottage away
  • Included: U.S. long distance calls
  • Excluded:  international calls
  • No pets allowed
  • No smoking allowed
  • Wheelchair accessible with new ramp added to kitchen entrance

Contact: Andrea Lohneiss

Hillcrest

Availability Calendar 2024: Not renting in 2024


Hillcrest is centrally located above the Hotel with a beautiful view of Lake Michigan.

  • Rental Fee: $2,200
  • Cleaning Fee: $275
  • Sleeps: 8-10
  • Included: Domestic long distance calls
  • No pets allowed
  • No smoking allowed
  • Not wheelchair accessible

Contact: Barbara Mustoe-Monteith

Isle of View

Availability Calendar 2024: June 17-July 1 and July 15-22


The cottage is centrally located across the Quayle Court bridge on the 3rd tier of cottages with a breathtaking view of Lake Michigan and sunsets. There are 2 water heaters to assure plenty of hot water as well as a full size washer and dryer. The kitchen is well stocked for meal preparation and serving. An outdoor gas grill is available for use. Five televisions are streaming capable. A port-a-crib is also available. Numerous pictures available upon request from owner.

Hulu + Live on 5 Roku TVs.

Non-refundable deposit of $500/week due at contract signing.

  • Rental Fee
    • $1,900
  • Cleaning Fee: TBD by renter with cleaning service
    • Cleaning Professional: Jan Jensen 231-690-4800 – paid directly to her
  • Sleeps 10 (8 twin beds & 1 queen size bed)
  • 3 parking spots: 1 in upper Hotel Sq & 2 on Burma Rd accessible by steps
  • Included: free domestic calls only
  • Excluded: Any miscellaneous charges (ex. golf, coffee shop) to be paid by renter.
  • No pets allowed
  • No smoking allowed
  • No fax machine
  • Not wheelchair accessible

Contact: Andrea Barnes

Happy Days

Availability Calendar 2024: TBD


Spacious property with direct access to beach. It is well maintained. Three queen size beds, one king and four twins. There is a pullout bed in living room with TV.

  • Rental Fee: $3,000
  • Cleaning Fee: $200
    • Cleaning Professional: Jan Jensen 231-690-4800
  • Sleeps: 12
  • Parking: 1 parking space at Lagoon
  • Excluded: Coffee Shop and Activities as well as any long distance phone calls made from landline.
  • No pets allowed
  • No smoking allowed
  • Wheelchair accessible

Contact: Lauren Bemenderfer

Glenside

Availability Calendar 2024: May – June 30 and July 7 – August 21


Glenside is a classic, comfortable Epworth cottage that has been kept as it was as our families grew up there. Set above the Hotel Square, you are close to all activities and the Coffee Shop and Hotel. Weekly rentals run from Sunday thru Saturday unless other arrangements are made. 

  • Rental Fee: $1,900/week
  • Cleaning Fee: $175/week
    • Cleaning Professional: Lina McManus 415-559-9887
  • Sleeps: 8+
  • Two parking spaces in Hotel parking lot
  • Long distance calling not available
  • No smoking in cottage
  • Not wheelchair accessible

Contact: Jim Langknecht

Blarney Castle

Availability Calendar 2024: prior to June 28 – July 29

Blarney Castle is a large cottage right on Lake Michigan!


  • Rental Fee: contact Les
  • Sleeps: 14
  • Parking: 2 – Lagoon parking lot
  • No pets allowed
  • No smoking allowed
  • Not wheelchair accessible

Contact: Les Lewis

Maryland

Availability Calendar 2024: Not renting in 2024


Maryland is a deceptively large, charming cottage which has received a number of updates over the years. Almost all of the original windows have been replaced as have both front and back decks. A full bath was added in the basement in 2005 and one of the upstairs bath remodeled in 2020. The master bedroom was remodeled in 2018. In addition to a ceiling fan, this bedroom also has a window air conditioning unit and base board heater. All other rooms have box fans. The first level hardwood floors were refinished in 2018. Maryland has many porches on which to relax, nap and play games. In addition to the dining room, the cottage has a large breakfast room on the back of the house which also serves as an office. There is a large desk and a printer/fax available for those who need to do a little work. Maryland has a nice view of the lake from the front of the house and a grass yard in front and back with gardens. This cottage has retained much of its original charm from the bead board paneling that is present in a number of rooms. 

  • Rental Fee: $2,750/week
  • Cleaning Fee: $250
  • Sleeps: 12-13 (2 queens, 1 full, 4 twins, 2 bunk beds and a daybed)
  • 2 parking spots right behind cottage with several more on the other side of the road which are not designated for any particular cottage
  • Excluded: Long distance calls and pay per view TV programs
  • No pets allowed
  • No smoking allowed
  • Not wheelchair accessible

Contact: Virginia McCoskrie